Intentional depreciation?! Why is the value of criminal assets in the catalogs half of the market value?

2026-11-18 22:21:22Aktualitet SHKRUAR NGA REDAKSIA VOX

Intentional depreciation?! Why is the value of criminal assets in the catalogs

If you specifically analyze the property bulletin, you will discover the loss that the state may suffer in the event of a lease or sale when the property is confiscated. An apartment with an area of ​​172 square meters near the center of Tirana has a registered value of about 16 million new lek. According to the reference price, the figure is about 22 million lek. But, according to the market, the real value of the property is over 35 million lek, that is, double. If this property is leased, it will be given at half the price, and if it is sold, the state loses a full half of the real value. Here we may be facing a scheme that starts with a court decision that has a fixed value, and concludes tomorrow in preferential auctions...

Another apartment with an area of ​​69.9 square meters in the Paris Municipality, has been estimated at 7.4 million new lekë. Referring to market prices, the real amount is around 15 million lekë. This property belongs to former member of the Supreme Court Admir Thanza who was dismissed from the Vetting process.

In the case of a seized apartment with a surface area of ​​93 meters located in the "Don Bosko" area, referring to the market, even in this case the value would be almost double what is specified in the property passport. From the rent, this asset could generate about 4 thousand euros per year.

A three-story building with a total area of ​​about 434 square meters, near the Student City, has an official value of 37 million new lek. In fact, referring to the market, the building costs at least 60 million new lek. If it were to be rented out according to the reference, the benefit to the state would be about 15 thousand euros per year.

In total, the four properties taken as an example above could generate a minimum of over 30 thousand euros per month according to the reference, a figure missing from the state's revenues.

But the problem is not only the missing money from rents. The biggest problem is the value of the properties with which they can be auctioned. So, if the properties are not revalued today, the state loses half of the value if we break down other concrete examples. In Tirana, one of the high-value assets confiscated in 2018, which is reflected in the catalog, is the 175 square meter shop in one of the luxury complexes on Kavaja Street. The property was valued at around 228 thousand euros at the time of confiscation, but today, it is worth 3 times more.

"Realistically, every property should be revalued at the moment it is put up for auction, whether for the first, second or third time. This is something that does not happen today, only an initial valuation is made at the moment the property is seized and it continues in the same form as then without making a revalua- tion. One of the reasons that the agency itself gives is that there must be licensed persons to do the revaluation and these must be paid. The agency says that it does not have enough budget to pay these licensed experts to do the revaluation of the property. Not having enough budget means that the property is left to depreciate for years and a property is depreciated without having the proper revaluation," said Gertjana Hasalla, an economic expert.

The situation is similar for properties in coastal areas. In Vlora, a building with a surface area of ​​3 thousand meters in the Uji i Ftohtë area was confiscated. In 2018, the building was worth around 2 million and 73 thousand euros, while today, it is estimated to be 3 times that. Only from the rents the state would have earned 500 to 600 thousand euros in 8 years according to the reference, which is "lost money"... Without forgetting the fact that the property is not evaluated, paving the way for its sale at auction at an abusive value with a loss of millions of euros...

If we take the hundreds of properties listed in the catalog one by one, the situation is identical. This reveals that the real value of criminal assets could be much higher than the official figure estimated at around 200 million euros.

"It can often happen that these criminal properties are left unused for years and depreciation occurs. There is a very big difference when talking especially about the assessment that this property receives from certain institutions. In this case, it is the confiscation agency ," said Gertjana Hasalla, an economic expert.

In addition to the lack of profit, leaving the buildings to chance comes in stark contrast to the state's need for various facilities for institutions. As we discovered in a previous investigation, paradoxically the state spends millions of euros on rented facilities while confiscated assets are often left to deteriorate...

"They should be made available mainly to the structures against organized crime, whether cars, boats or yachts, whatever things can be seized, but they should be given a destination as soon as possible. Computer parts, for example; the mafia works with very sophisticated computer systems, which, when seized, are passed on to the structures, whether the agency, the police or the secret services ," said economics expert Arben Malaj.

"Of course, if the amount of confiscated assets increases, we will also need intervention, but, given that society's needs are extremely great, the state's needs for assets are great, starting from cars, motorcycles, villas, apartments; we have somewhere to take them," said economic expert Pano Soko.

 


Video